Billy Penn/WHYY
•
6th July 2022
Violent crime is exceedingly rare on South Street, despite longstanding misconceptions fueled by the recent shooting
When an early June altercation on South Street spiraled into a shooting that killed three people and wounded 11, national news outlets played up concerns the area’s nightlife was encouraging violence.
A Billy Penn analysis of police reports along some of the most commercially active blocks of South Street, however, found that not only do shootings seldom occur, but the business district is also among the safest in Philly.
Some headlines in the wake of June’s South Street tragedy, which happened on a busy Saturday evening, compared it to mass shootings in Chattanooga and Buffalo with zero acknowledgement of how often physical violence in Philly escalates into gunfire.
“It’s the rhetoric around the incident that bothers me the most,” Jenea Robinson told Billy Penn. She owns Marsh + Mane, a natural hair care store on the corner of 4th and South that specializes in Black beauty products. When she opened the store in 2018, Robinson said South Street was one of the few neighborhoods that welcomed her business.
Now, she is dismayed by how the shooting was framed. “The details of the incident are being reported factually,” Robinson said, “but I think this was used in a political way to push a particular agenda.”
Eleanor Ingersoll, president of the Queen Village Neighbors Association who has lived adjacent to South Street for 23 years, told Billy Penn that shootings “don’t scare” her away from South Street, but they are concerning. These concerns manifest differently for business owners and longtime Queen Village residents. Everyone, it seems, wants to see the street become safer for all to enjoy, but there’s little agreement over what constitutes danger in the first place.
“I’m more worried about these low-level crimes creating a wellspring where ‘everything goes,’” Ingersoll said, arguing that city departments need to work together to monitor how bars, clubs, and BYOBs are enabling crime with lax policies around drinking.